Wednesday, May 18, 2011

Creating the Non-Stereotypical Character

How many times have you read a story in which the characters are boring stereotypes? You can guarantee agents’ and editors’ slush piles are filled with these individuals. And we all know what happens to manuscripts containing them.




Author Mary Buckham recently conducted a workshop through my local RWA (Romance Writers of America) chapter. Her exercise had us (including the published authors) salivating at the chance to try this with our own characters.

First, list five character traits associated with your major characters’ careers. If you write YA or MG (middle grade), then pick an activity/interest that’s important to them (e.g. football player, cheerleader, musician, Goth). I’m going to use the examples from the class.

Cop



• Emotionally strong
• Aggressive
• Self-sacrificing
• Cynical
• Gruff

(Okay, I know Orlando Bloom looks like none of these. So sue me!)





Nurse



• Compassionate
• Anxious
• Busy/rushing/stressed
• Intelligent
• Logical






Exotic Dancer



• Outgoing
• Likes to be the center of attention
• Driven
• Easy going
• Mysterious










As you might have noticed, these traits are subjective. Your perception of a cop might be different than someone else’s.

Now switch things around. Take the career title and move it to a different list. For example:

The cop is now:

• Outgoing
• Likes to be the center of attention
• Driven
• Easy going
• Mysterious

Your cop is no longer a stereotype, and how he deals with a given situation will be different than the cop from the original list. And this will make your characters and story less predictable.

Cool trick, huh?

(Note: The Bookshelf Muse announced yesterday their newest thesaurus: Character traits).

51 comments:

Laura Pauling said...

Great ideas. I think it all ties in with surprising the reader. And finding the character least suited or expected for the job like Blake Snyder suggests. I think I'll try this for my next idea. Thanks Stina.

Creepy Query Girl said...

that is neat! I guess my answer is to try and make them as life like as possible- using people I know from real life. I give them quirks and try to steer away from stereotypes as much as possible. I find physical description can help too- giving them not only personality flaws but small physical flaws as well.

Gina said...

So true. I think that's why cheesy romance novels annoy me so much. It's always hot girl, hot guy, one of whom is afraid to get involved, both of whom wind up saying terribly corny things... ugh! And the YA stereotype of teens who don't get along with their parents is way overdone, too. Good post!

Tessa Conte said...

Oh how true is that! And what a great idea for mixing things up a bit...

I like to remember that characters are never cookie-cutter perfect. People contradict themselves, they have issues because they don't quite fit into their chosen lives/the lives they 'fell into'.

Nobody is ever exactly what you expect them to be, so characters shouldn't be, either.

Joanne said...

I like this! It's interesting for the reader, and for the writer too. It's always fun to bring something new to a character, and to a story, in an unexpected way like this.

Summer Frey said...

hmm! Cool! Thanks, Stina!

Jen Daiker said...

I think this is really fantastic Stina! I'm currently molding my new characters and this will be very helpful! I also have a new writing book I'm reading called See Jane Write that so far is a lot of fun!

Tara said...

Oooh. I like it. Thanks :)

Jessica A. Briones said...

Great point, I am going to go makes lists!

Thanks

Lindsay said...

Great idea. Thanks Stina ;)

Lydia Sharp said...

Reminds me of the exercises in Don Maass' The Fire In Fiction. Very useful tips. Thanks for the reminder!

Anne Gallagher said...

Hey now, this is something! I am totally doing this from now on.

Jess said...

Wow~ that's just an awesome trick! It seems simple, but I never would have thought of it!! So cool, thanks for sharing :)

Janet Johnson said...

How fun! Definitely going to try this. :)

Jessica Nelson said...

Hahaha! Love it! My cop hero is actually a fairly laidback playboy BUT he is a big time rule follower, so that probably fits with the stereotypes.
Great exercise! Thanks for sharing this.

Patti said...

Love that trick.

Carol Riggs said...

That is a really COOL way to do it!! Thanks for the tip, Stina. ;o) Yeah, I've not only read stereotypical characters, I'm sure I've written my share of them, too!

lbdiamond said...

Ah, what an interesting take on characterization!

Steph Sinkhorn said...

Oooooh, nice! Handy trick :D

Ben said...

Great tip Stina, thanks!

Pk Hrezo said...

This is such a great exercize. BTW I always misspell exercize. DOH! I like this way of thinking. ANd I just downloaded Save the Cat to my Kindle and you are right!!! It is outstanding! Thanks for recommending it. :)

Christina Lee said...

VERY cool trick (And who knew that was Orlando?)!

D. U. Okonkwo said...

LOL - Oh, i hear what you're saying. Romance writers do liek to write about cops as heros, don't they? It's nice when mystery authors put a spin on their characters, or when horror writers make the MC seem so normal....but then changes it and mix it up. Definitely keeps you on your toes.

Solvang Sherrie said...

Oh, this is cool! Like the pictures, too, especially Orlando Bloom :)

Laura Marcella said...

That is a very cool trick! I've gotta try this out now. Thanks for sharing! Hope you're having a great week. :)

Monica B.W. said...

Totally!!! Super cool trick! :D Thx for sharing!

Marie Rose Dufour said...

Very good idea. Thanks for the tip.

Leslie Rose said...

Fun idea. I see character development lessons for my students using this technique. Yay.

Stephanie Faris said...

Great exercise. Although you have to be careful switching the "nurse" and "cop" stereotypes!

Michelle Teacress said...

Yes, that is a cool trick. Thanks for the idea. :)

Margo Berendsen said...

Oh, that is a fun trick! And I got an extra chuckle out of it, because my husband is close friends with 3 cops - one of them fits the stereotype perfectly, the other two fit the exotic dancer stereotype!

A.L. Sonnichsen said...

That is a fun trick. Thanks, Stina!

Amy

Plamena Schmidt said...

Ha! That is fun to play around with. Thanks for the tip : ) And omg, that burning picture is kind of scary.

WritingNut said...

This is a great idea! Thanks so much for the tip :)

Lydia K said...

That's a great idea! I never thought of that. I worry about my characters being too stereotypical.

McKenzie McCann said...

I think the best way to make interesting characters is to take elements from the people in your own life and mash them up with other ideas.

Meredith said...

Such a cool trick! I'm going to try this on my characters now--thanks, Stina!

Lisa Gail Green said...

Wow that is both simple and awesome!! I love that. What a fun exercise. Can the cop then look like the exotic dancer too? WHAT?? :D

Tana Adams said...

My husband was just leaning over my shoulder wondering why I was staring at an Exotic dancer. gee thanx Stina! ;)

Sophia Richardson said...

I thought you were going to suggest flipping each of the traits but I think I like this trick more! Thanks for sharing, Stina: the tips as well as the exotic dancer.
- Sophia.

Kelly said...

Good way to switch it up!

Lynn said...

Great exercise. I often think of the Robert DeNiro's character as cross-dressing Pirate Shakespeare in Stardust when trying to think of a non-stereotypical characteristics. How creative his character was!

hot girl said...

veri nice.

Susan Fields said...

What an awesome exercise - I'm definitely going to try that as I'm planning my new wip. Thanks so much for sharing that with us!

Heather said...

This sounds like such a fun excercise, and not just because your pictures rock! ;) But they totally do. In fact, I'm scrolling back up...

lisanowak said...

That sounds like a great trick. Thanks for sharing it.

LTM said...

Hey, that's a fun trick! I love it. Wish I had a local RWA chapter... very jealous. But you're keeping me up to speed. Thanks! :o) <3

erica and christy said...

Oooh! I love this idea and will use it. Thanks so much for sharing it! christy

Ghenet Myrthil said...

This is a smart technique. When I revise my WIP, I want to make sure none of my characters are stereotypical so I will try this. Thanks! :)

Kimberly Krey said...

I'm new to your blog and I loved the post! I've read several of your articles through QT, and I'm glad to have found your personal blog, as well.

I'm Just Sayin said...

Oh wow, that's a very nice idea. I'd never thought of it before, so thanks for sharing. I don't like stereotypical characters either...it makes me really sad to see STILL.