Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Writing Software Love





Last year, I reviewed the free version of SmartEdit and loved it. The creators recently asked me if I would test the new version (which isn’t free). In exchange for an honest review, I was provided a copy of the software.

PROS
  • One of my favorite parts about SmartEdit is the list it generates from your manuscript. It lets you know which words and phrases you use repeatedly. This helps you identify those annoying crutch words and phrases that you might not realize you’re using. And after you’ve gone through your manuscript to correct for this, you can rerun the program to see if you’ve created a new list of crutch words. This is quicker and easier than figuring out your crutch words and using FIND and REPLACE in Word.
  • SmartEdit not only lists the repeated words, you can click on the word (or phrase, depending on what you’re analyzing) to see the sentences you used it in. You can then edit those sentences that you wish to change directly in SmartEdit (or go back and make the changes in your word processing software).
  • The program generates a list of potentially misspelled or misused words so that you can ensure you used the word correctly (e.g. breath and breathe), or didn’t accidentally misspell it.
  • You can quickly check to see if you overused profanity (or a specific swear word), or if you accidentally used profanity when you didn’t want it in the story.
  • You can analyze your sentence lengths. The results are shown in a chart. If you have an excessive number of sentences at the high end of the scale (e.g. thirty or more words), you might want to consider rewriting some of these sentences.
  • You can analyze dialogue tags to ensure you aren’t abusing non-said tags.
  • Another of my favorite features is the feedback SmartEdit provides on the beginning of your sentences. It’s a great way to see if you abuse certain words (e.g. ‘but’ and ‘and’).
  • SmartEdit shows you when you’ve used too many spaces between words. A life saver for your eyes.
  • There is a short video to show you how to use the software. I recommend watching it, but I know where are some people who are more hands on when it comes to learning a new program.
  • If you use foreign phrases or non-English phrases (fantasy anyone?), the program will list them so you can double check that you’ve used them correctly. In the case of non-English phrases created for fantasy, it helps to ensure you’re consistent in their use (or spelling).

CONS

  • Unlike other editing programs, Smartedit doesn’t tell you how to fix the issue. This enables you to have full creative control of your writing. Personally, I don’t think this is a disadvantage to the program, but it depends on what you’re looking for.  
  • Sorry Mac users (which now includes me), the program is currently only available for PCs.
  • The program analyzes dialogue tags, but they are only available in past tense. I tend to writing novels in present tense, which means this feature has limited value for me. If I want to analyze them, I have to list the words under custom settings. This requires me knowing what dialogue tags I tend to use. The other issue is that you can’t save the list of words you compile under custom settings for future use.

Overall, I love SmartEdit. It’s the perfect program to help your polish your manuscript. It will definitely be part of my editing process.

Do you use any software programs designed for writers? Are there any you can’t live without? *

*I’m also a Scrivener girl.

42 comments:

Laura Pauling said...

Awesome. I've been thinking of investing in an editing program for things like that. Are there any good ones for Mac?

Laura Marcella said...

Very cool! I'm a Mac user, though. Any chance SmartEdit will be available for Mac in the future?

I have Scrivener but never got much use out of it because it seemed so overwhelming at first and I kept forgetting what I learned in the tutorial. I miss the days when programs came with a nice user manual! So my husband got me Scrivener for Dummies, LoL. It's terrific!! I'm really liking Scrivener now that I know how to use it and have a manual to refer to.

Meredith said...

Wow, that sounds incredibly useful! Too bad I'm a Mac user.

Slamdunk said...

I love how far they have come with these tools. Word repetition is always a problem for me. I am surprised that they don't have a Mac version as so many creative types prefer that system.

Anyway, welcome back Stina.

Julie Luek said...

I've read about a few great programs people are hooked on. I haven't invested the bucks yet, but may have to do so!

Pat Hatt said...

Never used one at all, but hmmm I may just have to give this a look.

Julie Dao said...

I've never heard of SmartEdit, but it sounds amazing... can you download it online?

SC Author said...

Never used one, but I keep hearing of so many -- this, Scrivner -- that I just might try one.

Southpaw said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anne Gallagher said...

Oh yeah, those crutch words, and find and replace are a nightmare. I can't tell you how many times I've wanted something to help me.

sounds great. Thanks Stina. And thanks for stopping by my other blog. I appreciated your comment.

Southpaw said...

It sounds like it provides a decent analysis. It's worth checking out the free version at least. The pro version is pricey but I can see where that would still be okay if you were actively publishing.

Donna K. Weaver said...

This sounds great. I have Scrivener but I don't think I'm using it right because I'm not impressed. So far. I'm going to check this one out. Thanks for the heads up!

Patti said...

I haven't used a software program, but like many others, I'm a Mac user so that program won't help. I like the idea of identifying crutch words.

Welcome back, hope you had a good break.

Deb Marshall said...

Scrivener is my software of choice. That and Word. But, just updated to the latest OS on my Mac and the word version I have is too old. Trying to decide if I really really need to invest again or just go with pages....

Johanna Garth said...

I'm always a little skeptical about editing software because I feel like there's no substitute for slogging through, BUT this seems like it would be good to help catch the line edit types of things and generally clean up a WIP.

Carol Kilgore said...

This sounds somewhat like AutoCrit, which I use.

Johanna, I still have to slog through, but the program is a beacon in the darkness spotlighting the major issues that I need to address.

S.P. Bowers said...

Smart edit is new to me. Currently I use scrivener but it's always nice to know what's out there so I like hearing about the others. Thanks.

Beth said...

What is the cost of this version?

Kristin Lenz said...

I keep reading recommendations for various programs, but the time required to get past the learning curve always stops me from doing anything different than plain old Word.

dianerinellaauthor said...

UGH! Why isn't this for the Mac?! The majority of the writers I know use Macs.

I would totally try this. My husband used to use Scrivener but lost an entire first draft because of the way the program handles (handled?) back-up devices. When the back-up device kicked in, his entire draft disappeared and was not recoverable. He spoke to the head guy at Scrivener who basically said, "Yeah, that happens."

If the SmartEdit people read this, please make a Mac version!

Martha Ramirez said...

This sounds like a good one! I use Right Writer. It really spots a lot.

Smart Edit sounds like a good one. Thank you for sharing.

L. Diane Wolfe said...

Don't think I have to worry about profanity, but I love the sound of this program.

Elise Fallson said...

I don't currently use a program for writers, but will most likely hunt around for one if I actually get my first novel published. Thanks for the rundown on SmartEdit, I'd like to see them come out with a mac version too.

Medeia Sharif said...

Cool. I've seen this before and I'm considering getting this.

Laura Diamond said...

Sounds like a great program.

I've yet to use Scrivener...

Natalie Aguirre said...

Sounds like a great program. I haven't used anything but Word so far. I have Scrivener but haven't tried it.

Karen Strong said...

Thanks so much for sharing. I'm a yWriter girl myself but this would be great for polishing. I'm going to check this out.

Traci Kenworth said...

Good to know, Stina!! I'll check into this!!

Christina Lee said...

This is a fair and honest review, Stina. Thank you!

Tara Tyler said...

sounds like a great program for writers, but i'm a "if it aint broke, dont fix it" anti upgrade, old fart! not really that old, but if i'm happy with something, i dont want it to change...unless there are major advantages. love my "ancient" heavy, ipad2! just upgraded my computer & phone - glitch, glitch here, glitch, glitch there...

ms word does the job, but the analysis features sound worthy!
is there a software developed that wasily converts a doc to kindle or ibook format? (not just an adobe pdf) i havent researched, but i figure you would know, ms guru!

and gorgeous new photo! call me envy!

Barbara Watson said...

I haven't used any editing/writing software. I've heard so much helpful stuff about them, however, that I will get to it soon.

Peaches Ledwidge said...

Lucy you. You have it.

LTM said...

you know, I don't use any of these tools. :P I downloaded scrivener, but it seemed like it would take longer to figure out how to use. So I just charged ahead in word--LOL! :D

But that part about repeated words sounds super valuable. And I like the dialogue tag analysis.

sounds like a great program! Thanks for the review! :o) <3

Susanne Drazic said...

I don't currently use any software programs for writers. I do appreciate you sharing the pros and cons of this software. Sounds like a great program.

Romance Reader - Nas said...

Thanks for sharing about SmartEdit, Stina. I will lokk more into it and all others mentioned in the comments, as I don't need a writing software but maybe something for editing would be good. At the moment just my eyes!

Tammy Theriault said...

i just use microsoft word, because i'm boring i guess :D haha...
love your new photo!!

Summer Ross said...

I'm going to try out the free version and see what comes of it. Thanks for introducing me to a knew program.

Michael Di Gesu said...

Hi, Stina,

Thanks for the review.... I have a Macbook...

But it does sound like an interesting program...

I don't use anything but ME at this point and I am happy that way. I use searches to check on overused words and "LY" and "ING" words... and that works for me.

AND ... HAPPY 2013!

Michael Di Gesu said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Beth said...

Believe it or not, I own Scrivener but haven't used it. I bought it in the fall but was reluctant to move a half-finished manuscript onto it. Everyone I know loves it, so I'll try it sooner or later.

Melissa Sugar said...

Awesome review of the software. There are far more pros than cons. That's what I thought, anyway, until I reached the end of your post and Uhg, read that it is not available for Mac. I was really into it and was chomping at the bit to try it. I need something just like this. Find and replace doesn't measure up to the features you've described.

I am a Scrivener girl, as well. I could not write without it. I don't know what I did before I had it. For most of last year, I was delighted with it and I only used a small portion of the available features. I read the manual, but some of the stuff was still so foreign to me. A few months back I read a book on my kindle, Writing a Novel With Scrivener, by David Hewson, and I learned about so many other features. Now, I am really a Scrivener junkie.

I read good things about a software program called MasterWriter, that helps with word usage and descriptive words, avoiding adverbs and unnecessary adjectives and many other similar features, but I have not tried it. It is pretty costly, but someone just told me that The Writer's Store, http://www.writersstore.com/masterwriter-for-creative-writers/ offers a thirty day free trial. The software runs about $180, and that's a bit much for me right now.

Thanks for the detailed review.

Rachna Chhabria said...

Smart Edit sounds good. I definitely need to try it.